Music from Big Pink

I can see why this has its fans but it just doesn't connect with me the way their other work does. The songwriting feels less inspired and the production, while technically impressive, feels a bit sterile. A few standout moments keep it from being a total miss.

I tried multiple times but can't connect with this at all.

Respectable effort with some genuinely strong tracks mixed in.

I keep trying to find something wrong with this album and I genuinely can't. The melodies are gorgeous, the arrangements are inventive, the lyrics are thoughtful without being pretentious. It just fires on every cylinder from start to finish.

Strong songwriting throughout. The production choices are bold and mostly pay off.

I tried multiple times but can't connect with this at all.

Incredibly overrated. One of the most baffling critical darlings out there.

I go back and forth on this — some days it's a 4, some days it's a 4.5. The inconsistency in my own feelings about it probably reflects the slight inconsistency of the album itself. But at its best, this is breathtaking.

Incredibly well-crafted. A few moments don't work but the highs are very high.

I can see why this has its fans but it just doesn't connect with me the way their other work does. The songwriting feels less inspired and the production, while technically impressive, feels a bit sterile. A few standout moments keep it from being a total miss.