In the Aeroplane Over the Sea

Incredibly overrated. One of the most baffling critical darlings out there.

Ambitious album that mostly delivers. There are one or two moments where they overreach, but the confidence and vision on display are admirable. The standout tracks here are absolutely world-class.

I appreciate what they were going for even if it doesn't fully land.

I can see why people love this but it didn't grab me the way I expected.

A high watermark for the genre. Essential listening.

Pushes the boundaries of the genre in interesting ways.

I remember exactly where I was when I first heard this and how it made me feel. Very few albums create that kind of indelible memory. The craft on display here is extraordinary but it never feels cold or calculated — there's real heart behind every note.

I've introduced maybe a dozen friends to this album and every single one of them has become a fan. That kind of universal appeal combined with genuine artistic depth is incredibly rare. This is the real deal.

Flawless execution of an ambitious vision. This is why we love music.