Dog Man Star

Has its moments but feels bloated. Would benefit from trimming a few tracks.

Really impressive debut that announced a major new talent. There are a few rough edges that betray inexperience, but the raw ability and creative vision are undeniable. Can't wait to hear what comes next.

The instrumentation is gorgeous throughout. Really well produced.

Pleasant listening experience but not something I'll return to often.

A very cohesive listen. The sequencing is particularly impressive.

Solid if unspectacular album that does exactly what you'd expect from this artist. The songwriting is competent, the production is clean, and there are enough standout moments to keep you engaged. But it never really surprises you or takes any genuine risks. I've listened to it maybe half a dozen times and I enjoy it each time, but I never find myself reaching for it over their better work. It's the kind of album that's perfectly pleasant background music but doesn't demand your full attention the way their best records do.

This is fine but I expected more given the critical consensus.